Mauricio Pochettino Believes Manchester United Must Sell Diogo Dalot as He Plans a Major Defensive Overhaul at Old Trafford.
Mauricio Pochettino is reportedly preparing to make some important decisions about Manchester United’s squad as he begins planning for the future, with Diogo Dalot potentially facing an uncertain future at Old Trafford. The Portuguese defender has been a regular member of the first team for several seasons, but questions about his consistency, defensive performances and suitability for the new manager’s tactical plans could make him one of the players considered for departure.
Pochettino understands that rebuilding Manchester United will require more than bringing in new players. The Argentine manager will also have to identify those who can genuinely contribute to his project and those who might need to move on to create room for better options. With United struggling to establish themselves among the Premier League’s strongest teams, there is growing pressure to make difficult decisions about the current squad.
Dalot is one of the players whose position could come under serious consideration. Although he has demonstrated his versatility by playing on both sides of the defence, there have been occasions when his performances have attracted criticism from supporters. His attacking contributions have sometimes been useful, but questions remain about his defensive positioning, decision-making and ability to maintain consistency throughout an entire campaign.
For Pochettino, these are important considerations because of the kind of football he wants Manchester United to play. His preferred approach requires full-backs who can contribute offensively while remaining disciplined defensively. He wants players who understand when to move forward, when to provide defensive cover and how to maintain the team’s overall structure when possession is lost.
The manager will not want defenders who leave unnecessary spaces behind them or make the team vulnerable during opposition counterattacks. This is particularly important at Manchester United, where defensive mistakes have repeatedly made it difficult for the team to maintain positive results.
Dalot’s versatility has been one of his biggest advantages, but Pochettino could decide that the club needs more specialised options in those positions. Rather than continuing with players whose performances fluctuate, the Argentine may prefer to bring in defenders who can consistently deliver what his tactical system demands.
Another important consideration is Manchester United’s financial situation. Selling players who are no longer central to the manager’s plans could provide additional funds for recruitment. United need improvements in several defensive positions, and raising money through departures could help the club pursue younger and more consistent alternatives.
Recent transfer speculation has already suggested that Manchester United could listen to offers for Dalot as part of a wider defensive rebuild. Former United chief scout Mick Brown has also discussed the possibility of the Portuguese defender leaving if a suitable offer arrives. However, this does not establish that Pochettino has personally demanded his departure.
Pochettino will also have to consider the importance of competition within his squad. Manchester United cannot continue depending on the same group of players regardless of their performances. Every position should have competition, and players should understand that their places in the starting eleven must be earned through consistent performances.
If Dalot remains at Old Trafford, he will have to demonstrate that he deserves an important role under the new manager. His experience and knowledge of the club could be useful, but experience alone will not guarantee him a starting position.
There is also the question of whether United should continue investing in a player who has already spent several years at the club without establishing himself as an unquestionable defensive leader. At 27, Dalot is entering an important stage of his career, and a transfer could offer him an opportunity to experience a different challenge elsewhere.
However, selling him without securing an adequate replacement would create another problem for Manchester United. The Portuguese international remains capable of covering both full-back positions, and his departure would leave the club needing additional defensive reinforcements.
Pochettino must therefore approach the situation carefully. He cannot afford to remove important squad members without having suitable replacements available. The objective should be to improve the overall quality of the defence rather than simply reduce the number of players at his disposal.
Another issue is the reaction of Manchester United supporters. Dalot has received criticism from sections of the Old Trafford crowd, including being jeered when substituted during the recent draw with Aston Villa. Nevertheless, former Everton chief executive Keith Wyness has argued that the defender has been treated unfairly and should not be made a scapegoat for the club’s wider problems.
That argument is worth considering because Manchester United’s defensive difficulties cannot reasonably be blamed on one individual. Several players have struggled, and the team’s problems have been connected to recruitment, tactical organisation and a lack of consistency across the squad.
Pochettino will need to examine the entire defensive department before making his final decisions.
Gary Neville has also stressed that Pochettino needs significant influence over Manchester United’s recruitment if he is to rebuild the team successfully. The former United captain believes the club requires substantial defensive improvements and that the incoming manager must identify which players can form part of his long-term plans.
Ultimately, Dalot’s future could become one of the important talking points surrounding Manchester United’s upcoming transfer windows. If Pochettino decides that another right-back would better suit his footballing philosophy, the club may have to consider accepting an appropriate offer.
For now, the Portuguese defender still has an opportunity to prove his value. He will need to show greater consistency, improve his defensive decision-making and demonstrate that he can be trusted in the demanding matches that define Manchester United’s ambitions.
Pochettino’s arrival is expected to bring greater competition and scrutiny to the squad. No player should assume that his position is guaranteed, particularly when the club needs significant improvements to return to challenging for major honours.
The biggest question is whether Dalot can convince the Argentine that he deserves to remain part of the rebuilding project or whether Manchester United will eventually decide that selling him is the right move.
One thing is certain: the new manager faces important decisions, and the defensive department will be among his biggest priorities.